American Indians and Freedom Essay

American Indians grow striven for liberty endlessly since the colonization in 1800s. unless for different American Indians, the comments of freedom vary a lot. For the chief Seattle, the author of bona fide school text OF CHIEF SEATTLES pact utterance 1854, the freedom crockeds the right wings to live with the reputation harmoniously and to keep their morality and traditions. For Carlos Montezuma, the writer of onlyow My People Go, the definition of freedom is very compulsory and stems from political rights. His freedom means the rights of managing the stuffs of American Indians entirely without the control of blanched man.From my point of view, the definition of freedom to American Indians is more than close to its political definition because the rights of treasureing the holy nature impart non be given if they lose the political rights. But I argue that the real freedom does non mean the absolute free. Moreover, the chief Seattle and Carlos Montezuma differ in the event about whether American Indians should repeat the forethought of colonists. For the chief Seattle, he thinks him and his people can look at the c atomic number 18 of colonists on the condition that the colonists will non destroy their holy nature.For Carlos Montezuma, he asks the colonists non to come in the issue of American Indians because the corrupt solicitude of the colonists. I think that American Indians can accept the management of the colonists if they can consume enough political rights. The vanquish way is to contend for a democracy musical arrangement and government for American Indians rather than just asking for leaving the control of the colonists. It is obvious that the two writers testify quite different understandings when they face with the same newsfreedom, as I mentioned at the beginning.The writer of AUTHENTIC TEXT OF CHIEF SEATTLES TREATY ORATION 1854 shows deep love to his ancestors and the things his ancestors leave for them. He use s unspeakable to describe its ancestors and hallowed ground, verdant valleys, murmur rivers and so on to describe his living environment. Also, the writer thinks that their religion is the Great Spirit and gives them in sombre hours of the night. Yet, in the perspectives of these American Indians, the colonists refuse to accept and celebrate the holy nature and ancestors of Africa Americans.The writer writes, Your God is not our God Your God loves your people and hates mine The citation indicates that American Indians in Seattle fear deeply that the compound come up will ruin their living environment, religion and traditions. Hence, for the writer, their freedom means the respect of their finishing. Nevertheless, Carlos Montezuma, the writer of allow My People Go, asks for all told different freedom. He writes, The Indian way is the only obstacle that stands in the way that hinders our peoples freedom. , when the Indians will get hold of the most help in this world , t he Indian. delegacy will cease to exist and the Indian employees in the Indian Service their personality is destroyedthey have nothing to say. These summon express the strong impulsive of American Indians to escape from the control of gabardine Americans because of the decadence of Indian Bureau. So, the definition of freedom to Carlos Montezuma is the rights to express their ingest willing and achieve more political rights. I quite agree with Carlos Montezuma because he wants to ask for more political rights.Even if the Big Chief at Washington promised that the new colonists will respect the culture of the American Indians in Seattle, he can soft renege on the promise without the political rights or the protection of the law. On the other hand, the chief Seattle and Carlos Montezuma own different attitudes towards the issue about the management of white American. Carlos Montezuma hastily wants to set aside the Indian Bureau dodging rather than improve the governance. Carlo s Montezuma writes, The Indian Bureau scheme is disparage. The only way to adjust wrong is to abolish it, and the only reform is to let my people go. The quote expresses the urgent willing of Carlos Montezuma to stop the run of the wrong system. He owns the opinion to escape the control of White Americans. However, I think that American Indians can accept the management of colonists only if the colonists launch laws to protect the American Indians and give them enough political rights. The opinion of stopping the run of the system is too arbitrary and naive. It is extremely possible that a ruder way to manage the American Indians acquired after the abolition of the old system.Carlos Montezuma cannot accept the management of White Americans at all. But the chief Seattles requirements related to the acceptance of the White Americans management mayhap is without much consideration. The chief Seattle writes, But should we accept it, I here and now make this condition that we will n ot be denied the privilege without molestation of visit at any time the tombs of our ancestors, friends, and children. The quote has implication that the chief Seattle will accept the colonial rule on the condition that the colonists will not breach their ancestors, friends and children. And in the same paragraph, the writer emphasizes the importance to protect their holly hillsides, valleys, plains and so on again.I argue that his thoughts and requirements be too premature and primitive. These are the basic rights for gay beings. Even these rights are promised to give these American Indiana, they are still far away from freedom, as I regard it. Therefore, the real freedom cannot be achieved both by abolishing a wrong system and all losing control or by asking for so limited rights and show miscellanyness or respect to the colonists. Of course, freedom definitely is not what the Chief Seattle thinks.He views freedom as the rights on the foundation of compromise and only asks for poor limited rights. Besides, for me, freedom in addition is not absolute like Carlos Montezuma thinks. It does not mean you can do what you want without others management and totally losing control. Freedom means you can own all the proper political rights under the protection of an dispassionate system or laws. The most significant issue for the real freedom is to create a right system or laws to protect the rights legally for these American Indians. No matter the chief Seattle or Carlos Montezuma, they both lack in the consciousness to create a right system or laws to protect themselves.If this kind of thing can be done, the existence of India Bureau or the colonial rule of White Americans does not matter to them at all. For this reason, it is so vital for American Indians and also other races to force the society to create a more and more impartial system ceaselessly. Works Cited Carlos Montezuma, Let My People Go An track delivered at the conference of the Society of Am erican Indians in Lawrence, Kansas, N. p n. p ,1915 Dr. Henry A. Smith, AUTHENTIC TEXT OF CHIEF SEATTLES TREATY ORATION 1854, N. p n. p ,1887.